|“||I just want to say, welcome everybody, to this year's Find Your Drink! There's one person who was really looking forward to this party 'cause they wanted our senior year to be bigger and better than anything before, but he cannot be here with us tonight. Instead, we're gonna pour one out in his honor. Now, I know some of you didn't like Monty, but I think we can all agree he deserved to live to see this day.||”|
|— Diego Torres|
Find Your Drink is a party where seniors try out different drinks to find out their preferred drink before heading off to college.
The party was initially supposed to happen in Beecher's house, but after his parents found out, the party was called off. Clay asks Cyrus and his friends to help him find a new location for the party but under a VPN.
At the party, Winston and Jessica play a game of Paranoia. Winston says Jessica’s life would be easier if Bryce was still alive and Jessica drinks to that, indicating he’s correct. Then Jessica fires back at him that he’s not as smart as he thinks.
Clay narrates that he’s never done drugs but at the party he smokes weed. Justin arrives at the party after all and the two get into an argument about Clay’s parents. Justin asks why he lied to them about the drug test and that his parents don’t trust him anymore. However, Clay retorts that they never did that’s why they drug tested him. Then he says they’re not Justin’s parents but his.
Charlie finds Alex watching a movie by himself. The two have some weed cookies and snuggle up. When asked how he learned to make them, Charlie said it was when his mother was sick. He learned how to make it to help ease his mother’s pain.
Clay approaches Zach by the piano. He apologizes to him about not telling everyone about Winston from the beginning. He finds out Zach can play piano, which surprises him. Zach says he was forced to learn how to play for 5 years. They then sing together. When Zach notices a girl staring at Clay, he gives him advice on what to whisper in her ear to get laid. If he manages, then he’ll get to drive his Audi. Later, he tries it out and it works. Once Clay and Valerie finish having sex, they return the party where her boyfriend confronts Clay. The two end up fighting and Clay punches him repeatedly before Justin pulls him off. Then he storms off after telling Diego and Winston “I will end you.”
Zach sees Chlöe for a moment. She tells him she’s doing well and she’s planning on going San Diego State. She thanks him for his help. Zach leans in to kiss her, but she says she has a boyfriend.
Diego and Winston discuss how they need to get to the bottom of things for Monty. Diego then asks if it’s true that Monty beat him. Winston confirms but says it’s out of context, they hooked up at the party but he didn’t want everyone to know he’s gay. He then tells Diego that Monty has to be innocent because they were together the night of Bryce’s murder.
After the party, Clay drink drives with Zach celebrating that he isn’t a virgin anymore. He then slips into a trance and starts to speed up the car until it topples over and crashes.